When a homeowner asks about metal roof vs shingles, it means one big question: which roofing option will hold up better for our house? At HUDCO Roofing, the goal is to walk you through the differences clearly so you can pick the roof that fits your home, your budget, and how long you plan to stay.
1. Defining the Contenders: Metal Roof vs. Shingles
We’ll start by defining what each option is, so you know what’s being compared.
- Metal roofing: This usually means steel or aluminum panels (sometimes copper or other metals) installed over your roof deck. The term “steel roof vs shingles” is often used since steel is the most common metal.
- Shingles: Typically asphalt or composite type shingles in residential use. They’re layered, nailed onto the roof deck, and are the most common roof covering in many areas.
When you compare metal roof vs shingles, you’re really looking at how each performs over time: in durability, weather resistance, cost, upkeep, etc.
2. Durability and Lifespan: Metal Roof vs. Shingles
A major part of the “which is more durable” question comes down to lifespan and how each material handles weather, wear and tear.
Lifespan
- Many sources say asphalt shingles last around 20-30 years in typical conditions.
- Metal roofs often last 40-70 years or more, depending on the metal, climate and installation quality.
- So when you’re thinking “how long will this roof last?”, a metal roof often gives you more years before you need a full replacement.
Weather Resistance and Wear
- Shingles can suffer from curling, cracking, loss of granules (in asphalt), damage from high winds or hail.
- Metal roofing resists many of those issues better: less susceptible to granule loss, sometimes better at high winds and impact.
- If you live in an area with strong storms, heavy rainfall, or wind exposure (like many places in Louisiana), durability becomes a very real concern.
Maintenance and Repair
- With shingles, you’ll likely see more frequent repairs: replacing missing or damaged shingles, addressing leaks.
- With metal, you’ll still need inspections (for fasteners, any dents, corrosion) but less frequent full-replacement cycles.
- A well-installed metal roof often means fewer disruptions over time.
So in the metal roof vs shingles comparison, metal usually comes out ahead for durability and lifespan — provided it’s installed correctly and maintained.
3. Cost Considerations: Is a Metal Roof Cheaper Than Shingles?
Many homeowners ask: “Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?” The short answer: not always in upfront cost, but over the long term the case can shift.
Upfront Cost
- Asphalt shingles tend to cost less upfront. For many homes, replacing with shingles is more budget-friendly initially.
- Installing a metal roof can cost significantly more per square foot — materials, labor, special fastening or flashing may raise cost.
Long-term Value
- Because a metal roof lasts longer, you might avoid one or more full roof replacements over the lifetime of the home.
- Fewer maintenance or replacement cycles mean fewer major expenses down the road.
- One article points out that while metal costs more now, it may “save money in the long run.”
So when you ask “is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?”, the answer depends on how long you plan to stay in the home, how often you’d replace a shingle roof, and how much maintenance you’re willing to do.
4. Other Factors to Weigh in the Metal Roof vs Shingles Decision
Durability and cost are big, but other things matter too. Here are some extra factors to talk through.
Climate and Environment
If you’re in an area with heavy storms, high winds, hail, or lots of sun, durability becomes more vital. A metal roof may handle those harsher conditions better.
Maintenance & Appearance
Shingle roofs may show wear earlier (curling, missing pieces). With metal, you’ll want to check for issues like fastener loosening, rust or dents (especially in metal types prone to corrosion).
Resale and Long-term Plan
If you think you may stay in your home for many years, investing in a metal roof now may make more sense. If you maybe sell in a few years, the lower upfront cost of shingles may appeal.
“Steel Roof vs Shingles” Nuance
Often when homeowners mention metal they mean steel roof vs shingles. Steel is a strong option — good durability — but quality and installation matter just as much as the material itself.
Upgrades & Program Incentives
In Louisiana you may have access to programs like Louisiana Fortify Homes Program (LFHP) which grants up to $10,000 to upgrade to a roof meeting FORTIFIED Roof Standard for storm resistance.If durability is key, that’s something worth knowing.
5. When Shingles Might Still Make Sense
Just because a metal roof often lasts longer doesn’t mean shingles are always the wrong choice. There are scenarios where shingles make sense:
- If your budget is tight now, and you plan to move in a few years.
- If your home has no extreme weather exposure, and you’re okay with re-roofing later.
If you prefer a particular aesthetic that shingles provide and are comfortable managing maintenance. - If you want the lowest upfront cost and are fine accepting a shorter lifespan.
In the metal roof vs shingles discussion, shingles remain a valid option depending on your priorities.
Why Choose HUDCO Roofing for your Decision & Installation
At HUDCO Roofing we bring both materials and experience to the table. Here’s why you should consider us:
- We can assess your home, evaluate whether a metal roof or shingles make more sense for your needs.
- If you choose shingles, we’ll install carefully and help you plan for maintenance and future re-roofing.
- If you choose a metal roof, we handle the specialized installation, flashing, proper fasteners and best practices so you get the full benefit of the longer lifespan.
- We help with related services too (roof repair, emergency roof repair, residential roof replacement, commercial roof repair) using trusted workmanship.
- We’re familiar with local conditions in Louisiana, and with programs like the Fortify Homes program that can support stronger roof systems.
Contact HUDCO Roofing for Roofing Services in Louisiana
When comparing metal roof vs shingles, the key takeaway is that metal roofing offers stronger durability and a longer lifespan in many cases, especially in challenging weather environments. Shingles remain an affordable and widely used option, but you’ll likely face more frequent replacements and repairs.
If your goal is a long-term roof with low maintenance, fewer disruptions and higher resilience, then going with a metal roof may be the wiser investment. On the other hand, if upfront cost is the main driver and you don’t mind trading off shorter life or more maintenance, shingles will work.
Ready to explore your roofing options? Contact HUDCO Roofing today at 318-584-0044 or visit our contact page. Whether you’re looking for a full residential roof replacement, need emergency roof repair, or want to upgrade to a certified FORTIFIED Roof system, we’ve got you covered.
Serving homeowners as your trusted Roofer in Baton Rouge, LA, Roofing Company in Lafayette, LA, Roofing Company in New Orleans, LA, and Roofing Company in Shreveport, LA. Let HUDCO Roofing help you make a smart, informed choice for your house.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which roofing option will last longer, metal or shingles?
A: Generally a metal roof will last significantly longer — often 40-70 years or more — while shingles often run around 20-30 years (depending on quality, climate, installation).
Q: If metal roofs cost more upfront, is it worth it?
A: If you plan to stay in the home for many years, need strong durability and lower maintenance, then yes a metal roof often pays off. If you’re only planning short-term ownership, shingles may be more cost-effective upfront.
Q: What about “steel roof vs shingles”?
A: Steel is a top metal roof option; when comparing “steel roof vs shingles” you’ll see steel brings strong durability, though cost and proper installation remain key.
Q: Will a metal roof save money on energy?
A: Possibly. Some metal roofs reflect more sunlight and absorb less heat than asphalt shingles, which may reduce cooling costs in warm climates.
Q: Can a shingle roof ever be a good choice in our area?
A: Absolutely — if budget is limited, climate is moderate, you plan to re-roof again later, and you select high-quality shingles with proper installation and maintenance, shingles are still valid.
